DOUBLE TAKE: Petaluma Clare Valley Hanlin Hill Riesling 2009 By Gary Walsh and Campbell Mattinson, The Wine Front
WALSH: Looks like it’s my turn to kick off this Double Take. No problem for me: I’m excellent at dribbling. I tasted this in a bracket of five 2009 Clare Valley Rieslings over not one, but two days and I have a feeling that the old boy and I will be pretty closely aligned on this one. It’s a good Petaluma and I like it. It’s of a clean and pure nature with pretty things like orange blossom and aniseed sprayed ’round its lemon head. Not a bitey acidic wine, rather softer, but still tight. It has very good length and a most attractive chalkiness lending textural interest. I think it will age well over the medium term and improve slightly in the shorter one. 92+ from me, although 93 would be fine too. Gary Walsh
MATTINSON:I had this around the 94 mark at first though I dropped it back a touch later. It’s like drinking pure lime juice, though that chalkiness through the finish helps to soften it. Seriously crisp and intense. No idea really how it will age, though I would (even given the quality) be drinking this over the next couple of years. The more you drink it the more simple it seems - not unusual for a young riesling of course, but if it’s going to age well I’d like it to be more piercing. Gorgeous wine to drink young though - for definite. Rated : 92+/93 Points Campbell Mattinson
Rated : 92+/93 Points - Alcohol : 12.5% - Price : $30 - Closure : Screwcap - Drink : 2010 - 2018