Opened the 08 Tally last night and it’s looking very good. If there’s a Dr Mattinson in the house, then I’d love a second opinion on this wine (not The Tally): it’s an important staple in many a good cellar.
Rich smelling wine, but has a certain freshness and vigour, which from what I’ve tasted to date, seems be a trait of the 2008 Coonawarra vintage. Fruit profile would best be described as being like blackberries and dark cherries and there’s dark chocolate, toasty spiced vanilla oak with a little mint and sweet leather. Full bodied, but fresh and lively (perhaps too much so at this stage as the acidity looks a bit too enthusiastic and nippy), with positive structural fine grained tannins and plenty of length - no holes along the way. Needs time for the acidity to settle (and I wish there was less of it) but, minor quibbles aside, an impressive wine nonetheless. Drink : 2014 - 2020+ 93 POINTS Gary Walsh, The Wine Front